The Agony of Church Discipline Carried Out

“If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church. And if he refuses to listen even to the church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector.” (Matthew‬ ‭18:17‬)

As my wife and I walked into the sanctuary, we were met with the same fellowship we always get. But on this occasion, there was a sense of angst as everybody waited for the elders to speak. You see, this wasn’t Sunday service. It was a members-only meeting.

And just about everybody in the room—including my wife and me—knew what this meeting was about.

With brevity and soberness, our pastor stepped behind the stand and led the members in prayer. He had notes on the podium, which meant he’d be reading off a statement. As he read the statement, you could hear a pin drop—even though most knew what was coming.

Was one of the pastors leaving? Did one of the pastors disqualify himself from ministry? Is the church having difficulty with finances? No.

A member of the church—one that had been my closest friend—was being removed from membership due to willful unrepentance. Biblically, this is known as excommunication, and as you might can tell, it’s a sensitive subject. It’s even more sensitive when it comes to your church, to your closest friends.

Though I knew the announcement was coming, my emotions—along with my wife’s—were flying all over the place. This man, along with his wife, were a groomsmen and bridesmaid in our wedding. They were our closest friends, those who we could go to talk about anything.

Even still, I totally agreed with the decision to remove him from membership. And I still do. It wasn’t simply because of what I’ve heard (because I trust my pastors), but more importantly, what I had experienced firsthand.

With that said, I am not writing this blog to get into details. To be honest with you, I am writing this blog to get this information, this experience, this heartache out of my head. Though it’s been roughly two years since it took place, there has been a massive burden on my heart. A burden on my heart so large, so heavy, so painful that I have dreamed about the situation numerous times.

Friend, maybe you have experienced this, too. It’s difficult. It’s a sensitive topic—definitely when it visits your church. You don’t want to offend, hurt feelings, or accuse—but you must stay faithful to Scripture. So what should you do when this happens to a fellow church member? In my opinion, there’s only one thing you can do: pray.

Pray for the person’s repentance, for that is what we all want. We want him to come home, or at least reconcile even if that means attending a different church in good standing.

Pray for the person to be humbled, for one cannot have godly sorrow without humility. There is no such thing as prideful repentance. Hearts grow harder, and so God needs to break it.

There are so many other things to pray for, but those are two main ones.

This blog is more for me than anybody else. Pray for me, friend. Two years later and it’s still such a burden on my heart that, sometimes, I just don’t know how to handle it. But I also hope it encourages you, because we must remember that nobody is too far gone.

3 Comments Add yours

  1. Charles says:

    Funny. My wife and I were the ones ex-communicated from our last church about six months ago. The reason? Failing to submit to our elders.

    You see, when I became a Deacon, I soon learned that the church was misreporting it’s income and had been for almost 2 years (reporting about 40k when the number was actually 150k). Then I learned that the preacher (not in any way a true pastor) was hiding his income in order that his federal disability benefits were protected. Then I learned that the preacher’s wife, a teacher at the local high school, had been providing the 75-80 member congregation and visitors with weekly bulletins and music that was on paper stolen from the school printed using school ink and school electricity during time that she was being paid to…teach. The final capper was one of the other Deacons had been installed at the same time as me. This “Deacon” was on probation for committing acts of aggravated sexual assault by a public servant (he was a former deputy who had been compelling sexual acts from a prostitute). The charges were pled down to official oppression and he surrendered his peace officer license forever. Not surprisingly, the preacher was his friend and knew about this at the time of his nomination and examination, but both lied to the examining board by failing to disclose his sexual immorality.

    You see, my wife and I called for the preacher and his minions to be accountable; to live up to the standards set in Timothy and Titus. That was the reason we were cast out of their “church”, where I had taught the men’s Bible study for the last two years. We demanded to be able to have the congregation vote on our expulsion, but the preacher and one of the “elders” insisted that they would only allow us to appear under their twisted, unholy, and non-scriptural process. Since we would not follow that process, and since regardless, we would never sit under these false teachers, we left with only the vote of the executives and not the congregation, whom would never be allowed to hear the truth anyway.

    I still fight bitterness daily and have to remain vigilant to keep myself from falling into Satan’s traps, but have already been asked to teach Bible study at our current church. I pray for those at my old church, especially leadership and hope that our Lord will not cause those unaware to be fooled into believing the wide path leads to the narrow gate.


    1. Blake Long says:

      I’m sorry to hear about your story. Painful. Just remember even a situation as bitter as that is for a reason. God is using it! Keep focusing on the Lord, not the situation. Thank you for your comment!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s